Thursday, 24 April 2025

Reform Leaflet for DCC Election - lies and mis-information

The Reform propaganda sheet for the DCC elections arrived yesterday - dog-whistle headlines. I decided to do some research and find out the truth.

471 MILLION IN DEBT

The real position (see below for more detail)

Devon County Council (DCC) maintains a moderate debt level compared to some of the most indebted UK councils. However, it faces significant financial pressures, particularly related to its Special Educational Needs and Disabilities (SEND) services.

Your Council Tax has gone up by 25% in just five years:

YES of course it has for a very good reason Between 2010 and 2020, central government funding for local authorities in England and Wales decreased by nearly 60%. This substantial reduction led to cuts in various services, including public libraries, refuse collection, road maintenance, and early childhood programs.

Increased Reliance on Local Revenue

Shift Towards Local Taxation: Councils have become more dependent on locally raised funds. In 2024–25, council tax is expected to contribute 53% of core funding, up from 36% in 2010–11.

Council Tax Flexibilities: To address funding shortfalls, councils have been granted greater flexibility to increase council tax rates, especially those responsible for social care services.

Rising Service Demands and Costs

Social Care Pressures: Spending on adult and children's social care has increased, now accounting for 65% of council budgets in 2023–24, up from 50% in 2010–11. This rise reflects growing demand and higher service costs.

Service Reductions: Conversely, spending on other services has declined significantly since 2010–11: housing by one-third, highways and transport, culture and leisure, and planning by over 40%, and youth services by 70%

“No more of this Woke nonsense”

“Woke” actually means Human Rights which is why Reform wants to take the UK out of the European Convention on Human Rights which the UK was instrumental in founding after WWII.  Human rights have been fought for over centuries - things like getting rid of slavery, women getting the vote, women no longer being the property of their husbands, gay men no longer being imprisoned, the list is very long. Every reform took years and was strongly opposed. Each one would have been “Woke” at the time.

Stop 200K salaries for incompetent bosses.

The DCC Chief Exec is actually paid the going rate for the job, and less than the CC Chief Exec. of Essex CC where Farage has his Clacton seat. Farage himself is not content with the going rate for his job, as we all know.

We will reduce rates for struggling businesses

Ha! Ha! What a joke! This is the party that has cut businesses off from the 450 million strong EU market just across the channel which added hugely to business costs and made everyone in the country poorer.

Fight against government rules (on social housing). Too often local people go the back of the queue.

NOT TRUE. The rules actually say, authorities have discretion to prioritise applicants with strong ties to the area, such as long-term residency or employment.

Council staff claimed over £3.5 million in just 3 years.

What are they getting at here?Devon County Council is the largest employer in Devon, with over 20,000 employees. This workforce supports a wide range of services, including education, social care, highways, waste and recycling, economic regeneration, library services, registration services, transport, and various support services such as finance, ICT, legal support, and personnel. If they all claimed for 3 years that would be £58 each but probably this is about travel expenses and other expenses involved with their job. Does Reform expect the employees to pay these expenses out of their wages?

£159,000 spent on language translation services.

So what! Deaf people need a BSL interpreter – my wife is a BSL interpreter who works alongside a deaf person so that person can have a full-time job. Part of this money will go on that. But of course, this looks like thinly disguised ultra-nationalism – if they can’t speak our language they’ve no business living in our country. Like the English speakers living in Spain for example.

£533,000 on their equality and inclusion team.

Straight out of the Trump-Musk playbook! What is wrong with this? It’s about fairness and treating all human beings with respect. DCC have to comply with central government legislation. The primary purpose of this team is to ensure that the council meets its legal obligations under the Equality Act 2010 and the Public Sector Equality. Website: Home - Equality, Diversity and Inclusion

Over £1.7 million spent on Council Staff electric car scheme.

WRONG! Like to hear the truth?

Devon County Council (DCC) offers an electric vehicle (EV) salary sacrifice scheme to its employees, enabling them to lease electric cars through pre-tax salary deductions. This arrangement reduces both income tax and National Insurance contributions for participating staff.

Cost to the Taxpayer. The EV salary sacrifice scheme is designed to be cost-neutral—or even financially beneficial—for the council and, by extension, local taxpayers.

Employees benefit from reduced personal costs for electric vehicles, while the council potentially saves on employer National Insurance contributions. Any risks are generally managed through agreements with third-party providers. 

DCC Debt - details

Devon County Council Debt & Pressures on Spending

Devon County Council (DCC) maintains a moderate debt level compared to some of the most indebted UK councils. However, it faces significant financial pressures, particularly related to its Special Educational Needs and Disabilities (SEND) services.

Debt Levels and Financial Position

While specific figures for DCC's total debt or Capital Financing Requirement (CFR) are not publicly disclosed, the council has not been identified among the UK's most indebted local authorities For context, some councils have accumulated debts exceeding £1 billion, often due to ambitious commercial investments DCC's financial challenges are more prominently associated with service delivery pressures rather than excessive borrowing

SEND Funding Pressures

A significant financial strain for DCC arises from its SEND services As of September 2024, the council reported a SEND budget deficit exceeding £160 million To address this, DCC entered into a "safety valve" agreement with the Department for Education, securing a £95 million bailout In return, the council committed to using £29 million from its reserves and implementing measures to reduce overspendingDespite these efforts, the council anticipated an overspend of £38 million on its annual SEND budget, surpassing the £31 million limit set by the agreement, necessitating further savings of £7.4 million citeturn0search0

Budgetary Adjustments and Service Impacts

In response to financial pressures, DCC approved a 4.99% increase in council tax for the 2024/25 financial year, the maximum permissible without a public referendum. This increase includes a 2% rise specifically allocated for adult social car. The council's revenue spending was set to increase by £43 million, reaching £743 million for the year. Looking ahead to 2025/26, the council plans to increase its service delivery budget by 5.9% to £784 million. However, £66 million of this increase is earmarked for addressing cost pressures, including inflation and national wage increase. To balance the budget, DCC aims to implement £22 million in spending cuts, which may impact various service.

 Comparative Overview

While DCC's debt levels are moderate, its financial challenges are significant, primarily due to service demand pressures and funding constrains. In contrast, some councils with higher debt levels have faced financial difficulties stemming from substantial borrowing for commercial ventures

DCC's approach focuses on managing service delivery costs and seeking government support to address deficits, particularly in SEND services


0 comments:

Post a Comment